Loading...
Except as otherwise expressly provided by law or Contract, no subcontractor, subconsultant, supplier, or other person or business entity shall be a third-party beneficiary to any Contract awarded in accordance with this Chapter 6, or to any modification or any resolution of any claim arising out of any such Contract.
(Added by Ord. 58-05, File No. 041571, App. 4/1/2005; amended by Ord. 108-15, File No. 150175, App. 7/2/2015, Eff. 8/1/2015)
Public Work Contracts Generally. | |
Requirements for Bids and Quotes. | |
Public Work Construction Contract Terms and Working Conditions. | |
Public Works to be Performed by the City; Bids by City Departments; Procedure Upon Rejection or Failure of Bids. | |
Office of Labor Standards Enforcement; Prevailing Wage Requirements. | |
Contract Requirements for Clean Construction. | |
Citywide Project Labor Agreement Ordinance. | |
(a) Public Works In Excess of the Threshold Amount. Except as otherwise provided by the Charter or the Administrative Code, any Public Work or Improvement estimated to cost more than the Threshold Amount shall be performed under Contracts awarded to the Responsible Bidder submitting the lowest Responsive Bid. To split or divide any Public Work or Improvement into two or more Contracts for the purpose of evading this Section 6.20 shall constitute official misconduct.
(b) Public Works Less Than or Equal to the Threshold Amount. Any Public Work or Improvement estimated to cost less than or equal to the Threshold Amount may be performed (1) under Contract or (2) by City employees. If the work is to be performed under Contract, the department shall obtain not fewer than three Quotes and shall award the Contract to the Responsible Bidder offering the lowest Quotation. If the department is unable to obtain three Quotes, the Award may be based on the Quote or Quotes received. For Contracts for Public Works or Improvements less than or equal to $10,000, no competitive solicitation is required, however departments are encouraged to solicit Quotes, especially from LBE Contractors, and award the Contract to the Responsible Bidder offering the lowest Quotation. The total contract value for Contracts for Public Works or Improvements less than or equal to $10,000 cannot exceed $200,000 per department per fiscal year.
The department administering the Contract shall maintain records as to whom the request for Quotations was directed and the Quotations received. It is the policy of the Board of Supervisors for contracting departments to make every effort to eradicate prejudice and favoritism in the Award of City Contracts. In order to effectuate this policy, Department Heads and their staff members shall collaborate with CMD periodically to create a list of Responsible Contractors qualified to perform various types of Public Work or Improvements for projects estimated to be less than the Threshold Amount, making every effort to include qualified, Responsible, and certified LBE contractors on that list. CMD shall be responsible for outreach efforts to make sure that certified LBE Contractors are aware of the opportunity to be considered for the list. The departments or commissions shall be responsible for evaluating and determining whether Contractors are Responsible and qualified to perform the various scopes of work.
(c) Estimates Required. For Public Works or Improvements in excess of the Threshold Amount, no Department Head shall recommend a construction Contract for or issue an order of Award without preparing detailed program requirements and detailed estimates for the work to be performed. There shall be a separate accounting for each work or improvement, which accounting shall include all direct, indirect, and supervisory elements of costs chargeable to such work or improvement. All such accounts shall be reported to the Controller and to either the Mayor or to the board or commission concerned, as appropriate.
(d) Comparison of Bids on Basis of Time of Completion or Cost of Compensable Delay. Department Heads may compare Bids on the basis of time of completion and/or the cost of any compensable delay, and any Contract awarded in consideration, in whole or in part, of the relative time estimate of Bidders for completion of the work and/or the cost of any compensable delay in completing the work, shall be subject to the provisions of this Chapter 6.
(e) Time for Award. Except when a Contract is funded by Federal or State grants or funds, all Public Work Contracts shall be awarded within 90 days of the date the City receives the Bids. Such time may only be extended prior to award of the Contract and only upon written agreement of the apparent Responsible Bidder with the lowest Responsive Bid and approval by the Department Head.
(f) Prequalification. Department Heads may require that prospective Bidders be prequalified to Bid either on a specific project or on an identified group of projects. The procedure for prequalification is as follows:
(1) The Department Head shall issue a prequalification statement. The prequalification statement may, at the discretion of the Department Head, be issued in conformance with California Public Contract Code Section 20101 and/or the California Department of Industrial Relations Model Pre-Qualification Questionnaire. The Department Head may, at his/her own discretion, apply the Model Pre-Qualification Questionnaire guidelines for scorable questions and scoring as the basis for any prequalification. The Department Head may also, at his/her own discretion, issue the Model Pre-Qualification Questionnaire with additional questions or may use an alternative questionnaire. The Department Head responsible for the Public Work may include in any questionnaire a request for special qualifications, experience or expertise necessary to perform the project or projects for which the prequalification is sought. For any project-specific information required, the department shall set objective scoring criteria and incorporate the criteria into any scoring procedure.
(2) The department responsible for the Public Work shall advertise any prequalification questionnaire in the same manner required for Bids, as set forth in Section 6.21.
(3) Prequalification shall be valid for not more than two years following the date of initial prequalification.
(4) A prospective Bidder may dispute a finding that he/she is not prequalified. The dispute and request for review must be in writing and received by the department within ten calendar days from the date the department issued notice of non-prequalification. The department shall then provide the prospective Bidder with the basis for its finding and any supporting evidence used in the determination. The department shall give the prospective Bidder the opportunity to rebut the evidence provided and to present evidence as to why the prospective Bidder should be found qualified. If a Bidder fails to avail itself of this dispute process, the department's finding shall become final without further notice. Failure to be prequalified shall not by itself preclude a prospective Bidder from participating in other or future prequalifications.
(a) Bids. All Advertisements For Bids for construction Contracts in excess of the Threshold Amount shall conform to and at a minimum require the following:
(1) Published Advertisement. The Department Head shall advertise for competitive Bids in at least one local newspaper, periodical of general circulation, or on a publically available website of the City's Office of Contract Administration and the department concerned. Such advertisement shall be published not fewer than 10 days prior to Bid opening. The department may, in its discretion, include in the published advertisement the amount of the engineer's estimate for the work to be performed.
(2) Award and Certification Required. All published advertisements and Advertisements For Bid shall contain the following language [wording in brackets should be chosen as appropriate to the department]:
In accordance with San Francisco Administrative Code Chapter 6, no Bid is accepted and no contract in excess of [the Threshold Amount] is awarded by the City and County of San Francisco until such time as [(1) for departments with boards or commissions, (a) the Department Head recommends the contract for award and (b) the board or commission then adopts a resolution awarding the contract]; or [(2) for departments under the Mayor, (a) the Mayor approves the contract for award and (b) the Department Head then issues an order of award.] Pursuant to Charter Section 3.105, all contract awards are subject to certification by the Controller as to the availability of funds.
Failure of a department to include such language in a published advertisement or Advertisement For Bids does not give rise to a contract right by a Bidder or Contractor outside of the requirements of the Charter or Administrative Code.
(3) Form of Bid. All Bids shall be sealed and directed to the Department Head advertising for Bids, in the format prescribed by the Department Head.
(4) Bid Security Requirement. All Bids shall be accompanied by a corporate surety bond, or an irrevocable standby letter of credit on a bank or trust company doing business and having an office in the State of California, having a combined capital and surplus of at least $50,000,000, and subject to supervision or examination by Federal or State authority, or a certified check on a bank or trust company doing business and having an office in the State of California, having a combined capital and surplus of at least $50,000,000, and subject to supervision or examination by Federal or State authority, payable on sight to the City and County of San Francisco, the amount of which corporate surety bond, irrevocable standby letter of credit, or certified check shall be fixed by the Department Head or officer as stated in the Advertisement For Bids, which amount shall not be less than 10% of the amount Bid for the cost of the proposed work of improvement, and no Bid shall be considered unless accompanied by a corporate surety bond or irrevocable standby letter of credit or certified check. Any irrevocable standby letter submitted pursuant to this Chapter shall be on a form provided by the City. If the amount of security required is fixed by the Department Head or officer in an amount in excess of $15,000, the form of security required shall be that of a corporate surety bond or irrevocable standby letter of credit. The requirement for a corporate surety bond, irrevocable standby letter of credit, or certified check described in this subsection shall be referred to collectively as the "bid security requirements."
Notwithstanding the above, the bid security requirements for a particular Contract may be modified by the Department Head in accordance with Administrative Code Chapter 14B.
(5) Fees. The Department Head or officer calling for Bids may specify in the Advertisement For Bids for any project a nonrefundable fee to be paid by each prospective Bidder for each set of Bidding documents (including plans and specifications), such fee to defray the cost of reproducing each set of Bidding documents as determined by the Department Head or officer, and all such fees shall be deposited as an abatement of the expenditure of the appropriation against which the cost of reproducing said Bidding documents was charged.
(6) License. The Department Head shall specify in all Advertisements For Bids and plans for Public Work projects the classification of the Contractor's license which a Contractor shall possess at the time Bids are submitted. Except as provided in California Business and Professions Code Section 7000 et seq., Bidders and their subcontractors are required to be properly licensed at the time of Bid.
(7) Qualifications. The Department Head responsible for the Public Work shall require from all Bidders information concerning their experience and financial qualifications, and shall take such information into consideration in the Award of any Contract. At a minimum the Department Head shall require (A) information concerning the Contractor's experience, financial qualifications and ability to perform the terms and conditions of the Contract, and (B) information as to whether the Contractor possesses, or can obtain in time to perform the Contract, the necessary equipment. A Department Head may satisfy this requirement through a Bidder prequalification process that meets the requirement of Section 6.20(f).
(8) Business Tax Registration Certificate. All Advertisement For Bids shall require that Bidders submit proof of a current Business Tax Registration Certificate. Failure of a Bidder to provide such proof prior to Award, or as otherwise required in the Advertisement For Bids, could, at the discretion of the Department Head, constitute a refusal to enter into the Contract and result in a forfeiture of the Bid bond.
(9) Designation of Subcontractors; Subcontracting and Subletting. All Bidders shall designate their subcontractors in accordance with and shall be subject to the Subletting and Subcontracting Fair Practices Act, at California Public Contract Code Section 4100 et seq., as amended from time-to-time. In addition to the penalties provided by Public Contract Code Section 4100 et seq., violation of this subsection 6.21(a)(9) may be grounds for a determination of nonresponsibility under Article V of this Chapter 6.
(10) Work to Be Performed by General Contractor. The Advertisement For Bids may specify the scope of work which must be performed by the General Contractor using his/her own forces, or the specification may require the General Contractor to perform with his/her own forces up to 25% of the base Contract work. Bidders must certify with their Bids that, if awarded the Contract, they will perform with their own forces the specified scope or percentage of the total bid price (excluding alternate Bid items).
(b) Quotes. All requests for Quotes for construction Contracts less than or equal to the Threshold Amount shall be posted with three-days' notice. Such requests shall at a minimum require a Contractor's license, qualifications, a Business Tax Registration Certificate, participation in an apprenticeship program and compliance with subcontractor listing laws, all in accordance with the listed provisions of Sections 6.21 and 6.22.
(c) Right to Reject Any or All Bids or Quotes. The Department Head shall have the right to reject any or all Bids or Quotes for any reason or no reason. All Advertisement For Bids shall reserve this right, but failure to make such reservation shall not abrogate the right to reject.
(d) Bid Protests. Only a Bidder may submit a bid protest. The Department Head concerned shall prescribe in the Advertisement For Bids procedures for submitting Bid protests. Such procedures shall set the time by which Bid protests must be received but may not require that Bid protests be submitted fewer than five business days after the date Bids are due.
(Added by Ord. 286-99, File No. 991645, App. 11/5/99; amended by Ord. 153-00, File No. 000805, App. 6/30/2000; Ord. 324-00, File No. 001919, App. 12/28/2000; Ord. 7-02, File No. 011675, App. 1/25/2002; Ord. 208-02, File No. 021221, App. 10/18/02; Ord. 58-05, File No. 041571, App. 4/1/2005; Ord. 19-10, File No. 091163, App. 2/10/2010; Ord. 108-15, File No. 150175, App. 7/2/2015, Eff. 8/1/2015; Ord. 220-20, File No. 200949, App. 11/6/2020, Eff. 12/7/2020)
![](https://export.amlegal.com/media/46db6a2ad42b2315973c5e4ca7298259402b7394/IMAGES/0-0-0-11760.png)
Publisher's Note: This section has been AMENDED by new legislation (Ord. 296-24
, approved 12/19/2024, effective 1/19/2025, oper. 2/19/2025). The text of the amendment will be incorporated under the new section number when the amending legislation is operative.
All construction Contracts awarded under this Chapter 6 by the City shall contain the following minimum terms and conditions:
(a) Bonds. Before the execution of any Contract for Public Work or Improvement in excess of $25,000, the Department Head shall require the successful Bidder to file corporate surety bonds for the faithful performance thereof and to guarantee the payment of wages for services engaged and of bills contracted for material, supplies and equipment used in the performance of the Contract. Each bond shall be for a sum not less than 100% of the awarded Contract amount.
The City, acting through the City Administrator, intends to provide guarantees to private bonding assistance companies and financial institutions in order to induce those entities to provide required bonding and financing to eligible Contractors bidding on and performing City Public Work Contracts. This bonding and financial assistance program is subject to the provisions of Administrative Code Chapter 14B.
(b) Insurance. All construction Contracts awarded under this Chapter 6 must conform to the insurance requirements established by the Risk Manager. The Risk Manager shall develop uniform insurance requirements for City Contracts subject to this Chapter 6. The Risk Manager shall review and update such insurance requirements as necessary to protect the City’s interests.
Every Contractor and subcontractor shall comply with the provisions of California Labor Code Section 3700. Prior to commencing the performance of work under any Public Work Contract, the Contractor and all of its subcontractors shall file with the awarding department a certificate of insurance against liability for workers compensation or proof of self-insurance in accordance with the provisions of the California Labor Code.
(c) Indemnification. All construction Contracts awarded under this Chapter 6 shall require that the Contractor fully indemnify the City to the maximum extent provided by law, such that each Contractor must save, keep, bear harmless and fully indemnify the City and any of its officers or agents from any and all liability, damages, claims, judgments or demands for damages, costs or expenses in law or equity that may at any time arise.
This indemnification requirement may not be waived or abrogated in any way for any Contract without the recommendation of the Risk Manager and the express permission and approval of the Board of Supervisors.
(d) Assignment. No Contract shall be assigned except upon the recommendation of the Department Head concerned and with the approval of the Mayor, relative to the department under the Mayor's jurisdiction, or the approval of the board or commission concerned for departments not under the Mayor.
(e) Prevailing Wages.
(1) Generally. All Contractors and subcontractors performing a Public Work or Improvement for the City shall pay its workers on such projects the Prevailing Rate of Wages as provided below. For the purpose of Prevailing Wage requirements only, the definition of a public work shall include Public Works or Improvements as defined in the Section 6.1, and shall also include (A) any trade work performed at any stage of construction (including preconstruction work) and (B) any public work paid for by the City with "the equivalent of money" under the meaning of California Labor Code Section 1720(b).
(2) Additional Projects Considered as "Public Works or Improvements" for Purposes of Prevailing Wages.
(A) Property Leased or Sold by the City. For construction work performed on real property leased by the City or sold by the City for Housing Development, as that term is defined in Administrative Code subsection 23.61(a), Contractors and subcontractors must pay prevailing wages in accordance with Article VII of Chapter 23 of the Administrative Code and this subsection 6.22(e) as applicable.
(B) Public Works Under California Labor Code. For the limited purposes of this subsection 6.22(e) and Section 6.24, a "public work or improvement" also means and includes all projects for "public works" as defined in California Labor Code Section 1720, and projects for which Prevailing Wages are required to be paid pursuant to California Labor Code Section 1782. This subsection 6.22(e)(2)(B) is intended to have prospective effect only, and shall not be interpreted to impair the obligations of any pre-existing grant agreement, lease, development agreement or other contract entered into by the City. Notwithstanding the prior sentence, this subsection shall apply to newly included work in pre-existing grant agreements, leases, development agreements, or other contracts amended on or after the operative date. The subsection shall apply to grant agreements, leases, development agreements and other contracts entered into by the City on or after the operative date. All grant agreements, leases, development agreements and other contracts which allow for such construction on property owned by the City that the City enters after the operative date of the subsection must contain a provision that such construction shall comply with this subsection.
(3) Determination of the Prevailing Wage. It shall be the duty of the Board of Supervisors, from time to time and at least once during each calendar year, to fix and determine the Prevailing Rate of Wages as follows:
On or before the first Monday in November of each year, the Civil Service Commission shall furnish to the Board of Supervisors data as to the highest general Prevailing Rate of Wages of the various crafts and kinds of labor as paid in private employment in the City and County of San Francisco, plus "per diem wages" and wages for overtime and holiday work. The Civil Service Commission shall provide the Board of Supervisors data for "per diem wages" pursuant to California Labor Code Sections 1773.1 and 1773.9, as amended from time to time. The Board of Supervisors shall, upon receipt of such data, fix and determine the Prevailing Rate of Wages. The Prevailing Rate of Wages as so fixed and determined by the Board of Supervisors shall remain in force and shall be deemed to be the highest general Prevailing Rate of Wages paid in private employment for similar work, until the same is changed by the Board of Supervisors. In determining the highest general Prevailing Rate of Wages per diem wages and wages for overtime and holiday work, as provided for in this section, the Board of Supervisors shall not be limited to the consideration of data furnished by the Civil Service Commission, but may consider such other evidence upon the subject as the Board shall deem proper and thereupon base its determination upon any or all of the data or evidence considered.
In the event that the Board of Supervisors does not fix or determine the highest general Prevailing Rate of Wages in any calendar year, the rates established by the California Department of Industrial Relations for such year shall be deemed adopted.
(4) Specifications to Include Wage Rate. The Department Head shall include in the contract specifications, or make available in the offices of the department or at the job site, a detailed statement of the Prevailing Rate of Wages as fixed and determined by the Board of Supervisors at the time the department issued the Advertisement For Bids on the contract. The Contractor shall agree to pay to all persons performing labor in and about the Public Work or Improvement the highest general Prevailing Rate of Wages as determined pursuant to this Chapter, including wages for holiday and overtime work. If the specifications do not include the Prevailing Rate of Wages, the specifications shall include a statement that copies of the Prevailing Rate of Wages as fixed and determined by the Board of Supervisors are on file at the department's principal office or at the job site and shall be made available to any interested party on request.
(5) Subcontractors Bound by Wage Provisions. Every contract for any Public Work or Improvement shall also contain a provision that the Contractor shall insert in every subcontract or other arrangement which he or she may make for the performance of any work or labor on a Public Work or Improvement. This provision shall be that the subcontractor shall pay to all persons performing labor or rendering service under said subcontract or other arrangement the highest general Prevailing Rate of Wages as fixed and determined by the Board of Supervisors for such labor or services.
(6) Records to be Kept by Contractors and Subcontractors. Every Public Works contract or subcontract for any Public Work or Improvement shall contain a provision that the Contractor shall keep, or cause to be kept, for a period of four years from the date of substantial completion of a public work, payrolls and basic records including time cards, trust fund forms, apprenticeship agreements, accounting ledgers, tax forms and superintendent and foreman daily logs for all trades workers performing work at or for a City Public Work or Improvement. Such records shall include the name, address and social security number of each worker who worked on the project, including apprentices, his or her classification, a general description of the work each worker performed each day, the rate of pay (including rates of contributions for, or costs assumed to provide fringe benefits), daily and weekly number of hours worked, deductions made and actual wages paid. Every subcontractor who shall undertake the performance of any part of a Public Work or Improvement shall keep a like record of each person engaged in the execution of the subcontract.
The Contractor shall maintain weekly certified payroll records for submission to the awarding department as required. The Contractor shall be responsible for the submission of payroll records of its subcontractors. All certified payroll records shall be accompanied by a statement of compliance signed by the Contractor indicating that the payroll records are correct and complete, that the wage rates contained therein are not less than those determined by the Board of Supervisors and that the classifications set forth for each employee conform with the work performed.
All such records as described in this section shall at all times be open to inspection and examination of the duly authorized officers and agents of the City, including representatives of the Office of Labor Standards Enforcement.
Should the Department Head responsible for the public work or the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer determine that a Contractor or subcontractor is not in compliance with the requirements of this subsection, the Department Head or the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer shall issue written notification to the Contractor or subcontractor mandating compliance within not fewer than 10 calendar days from the date of the notification. Should the Contractor or subcontractor fail to comply as required in the notification, the Department Head who executed the Contract or the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer may impose penalties consistent with analogous provisions of the California Labor Code, including Section 1776, as amended from time to time, for each calendar day of noncompliance, or portion thereof, for each worker. Upon the request of the responsible Department Head or the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer, the Controller shall withhold these penalties from progress payments then due or to become due.
(7) Additional Required Contract Provisions. Every public works Contract shall contain provisions stating that (A) the Contractor will cooperate fully with the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer and other City employees and agents authorized to assist in the administration and enforcement of the Prevailing Wage requirements and other labor standards imposed on Public Works Contractor by the Charter and Chapter 6 of the San Francisco Administrative Code; (B) the Contractor agrees that the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer and his or her designees, in the performance of their duties, shall have the right to engage in random inspections of job sites and to have access to the employees of the Contractor, employee time sheets, inspection logs, payroll records and employee paychecks; (C) the contractor shall maintain a sign-in and sign-out sheet showing which employees are present on the job site; (D) the Contractor shall prominently post at each job-site a sign informing employees that the project is subject to the City's Prevailing Wage requirements and that these requirements are enforced by the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer; and (E) that the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer may audit such records of the Contractor as he or she reasonably deems necessary to determine compliance with the Prevailing Wage and other labor standards imposed by the Charter and this Chapter on Public Works Contractors. Failure to comply with these requirements may result in penalties and forfeitures consistent with analogous provisions of the California Labor Code, including Section 1776(g), as amended from time to time.
(8) Non-compliance with Wage Provisions – Penalties.
(A) Penalty and Forfeiture. Any Contractor or subcontractor who shall fail or neglect to pay to the several persons who shall perform labor under any contract, subcontract or other arrangement on any public work or Improvement as defined in this Chapter the highest general Prevailing Rate of Wages as fixed by the Board of Supervisors under authority of this Chapter, shall forfeit; and, in the case of any subcontractor so failing or neglecting to pay said wage, the original Contractor and the subcontractor shall jointly and severally forfeit to the City back wages due plus penalties in amounts consistent with analogous provisions of the California Labor Code as amended from time to time, including Sections 1775 and 1813, but not less than $50 per day for each laborer, workman or mechanic employed for each calendar day or portion thereof, while they shall be so employed and not paid said highest general Prevailing Rate of Wages, and in addition shall be subject to the penalties set forth in Article V of this Chapter 6, including debarment.
(B) Enforcement.
(i) For a public work or improvement undertaken through a contract with the City and under which the City has the ability to withhold funds, it shall be the duty of the officer, board or commission under whose jurisdiction said Public Work or Improvement is being carried on, made or constructed, when certifying to the Controller any payment which may become due under said contract, to deduct from said payment or payments the total amount of said forfeiture provided for in this subsection. In doing so, the Department Head must also notify in writing the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer of his/her action. The Labor Standards Enforcement Officer may also upon written notice to the Department Head who is responsible for the project, certify to the Controller any forfeiture(s) to deduct from any payment as provided for in this subsection 6.22(e)(8). Certification of forfeitures under this subsection shall be made only upon an investigation and audit by the responsible Department Head or the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer and upon service of written notice to the Contractor that includes identification of the grounds for the forfeiture or forfeitures ("Certification of Forfeiture"). The audit supporting the forfeiture shall be appended to the Certification of Forfeiture, but failure to append such documentation shall not invalidate the Certification. Service of the Certification of Forfeiture shall be made by United States mail and the date of service shall be the date of mailing. The Controller, in issuing any warrant for any such payment, shall deduct from the amount which would otherwise be due on said payment or payments the amount of said forfeiture or forfeitures as so certified.
(ii) For any contract in which the City has required a third party to pay prevailing wages and for which the City does not have the ability to withhold funds, the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer shall determine whether a contractor and/or any subcontractor has failed to comply with the prevailing wage requirement. If after conducting an investigation, the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer determines that a violation has occurred, it shall issue to and serve a Determination of Violation on the contractor and/or any subcontractor, which sets forth the basis of the determination and orders payment of back wages due plus the penalty of at least $50 per day for each laborer, workman, or mechanic employed for each calendar day or portion thereof. Service of the Determination of Violation shall be made by United States mail and the date of service shall be the date of mailing.
(C) Recourse Procedure. A Contractor and/or a subcontractor may appeal from a Certification of Forfeiture under subsection 6.22(e)(8)(B)(i) or Determination of Violation under subsection 6.22(e)(8)(B)(ii). The Controller shall adopt and maintain rules and regulations for any appeal under this subsection 6.22(e)(8)(C), which rules shall be consistent with the following parameters:
(i) Any Appeal from Certification of Forfeiture or Determination of Violation (referred to in this subsection 6.22(e)(8)(C) as the "Appeal") shall be filed in writing by the Contractor and/or subcontractor (referred to in this subsection 6.22(e)(8)(C), whether singular or plural, as the "Appellant") within 15 days of the date of service of the Certification of Forfeiture or Determination of Violation. Appellant shall file the Appeal with the City Controller and serve a copy on the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer. Failure by the Contractor or subcontractor to submit a timely, written Appeal shall constitute concession to the forfeiture or determination, and the forfeiture or determination shall be deemed final upon expiration of the 15-day period.
(ii) The Office of Labor Standards Enforcement shall promptly afford Appellant an opportunity to meet and confer in good faith regarding possible resolution of the Certification of Forfeiture or Determination of Violation in advance of further proceedings under this subsection 6.22(e)(8)(C), with the intention that such meeting occur within 30 days of the date the Appeal is filed.
(iii) After the expiration of 30 days following the date the Appeal is filed, any party may request in writing, with concurrent notice to all other parties, that the Controller appoint a hearing officer to hear and decide the Appeal. If no party requests appointment of a hearing officer, the Certification of Forfeiture or Determination of Violation shall be deemed final on the 60th day after the date the Appeal is filed.
(iv) Within 15 days of receiving a written request for appointment of a hearing officer under subsection 6.22(e)(8)(C)(iii), the Controller shall appoint an impartial hearing officer and immediately notify the enforcing official and Appellant, and their respective counsel or authorized representative if any, of the appointment. The appointed hearing officer shall be an Administrative Law Judge with at least 10 years' experience with the City and not less than two years experience in labor law, Prevailing Wage, and/or wage and hour matters; or shall be an attorney with knowledge and not less than five years' experience in labor law, Prevailing Wage, and/or wage and hour matters.
(v) The hearing officer shall promptly set a date for a hearing. The hearing must commence within 45 days of the date of the notification of the hearing officer appointment, and conclude within 75 days of such notice. The hearing officer shall conduct a fair and impartial evidentiary hearing in conformance with the time limitations set forth in this subsection 6.22(e)(8)(C) and in the rules and regulations, so as to avoid undue delay in the resolution of any appeal. The hearing officer shall have the discretion to extend the times under this subsection 6.22(e)(8)(C), and any time requirements under the rules and regulations, only upon a showing of good cause.
(vi) Appellant has the burden of proving by a preponderance of the evidence that the basis for the Certification of Forfeiture or Determination of Violation is incorrect, including any back wage and penalty assessments that are at issue in the appeal.
(vii) Within 30 days of the conclusion of the hearing, the hearing officer shall issue a written decision affirming, modifying, or dismissing the Certificate of Forfeiture or Determination of Violation. The decision of the hearing officer shall consist of findings and a determination. The hearing officer's findings and determination shall be the final determination.
(viii) Appellant may appeal a final determination under this subsection 6.22(e)(8) only by filing in the San Francisco Superior Court a petition for a writ of mandate under California Code of Civil Procedure, Section 1084, et seq., as applicable and as may be amended from time to time.
(D) Distribution of Forfeiture and Damages. The Controller shall withhold any forfeiture as provided in the foregoing paragraphs until such time as either the Contractor or subcontractor has conceded to the forfeiture or, in the event of an Appeal, there is a determination no longer subject to judicial review. The Controller shall then distribute the amounts withheld in the following order: (1) the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer shall make best efforts to distribute back wages withheld to the individual workers identified as not having been paid the proper wage rate; (2) the penal sums provided for above shall inure to the benefit of the general fund of the City; (3) the Controller shall hold the balance of any back wages in escrow for workers who the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer, despite his or her best efforts, cannot locate. In the event back wages are unclaimed for a period of three years, the Controller shall undertake administrative procedures for unclaimed funds in conformance with California Government Code Section 50050, et seq., as may be amended from time to time. This subsection 6.22(e)(8)(D) also shall be applicable to damages obtained as a result of an enforcement action pursuant to subsection 6.22(e)(8)(E), as applicable.
(E) Remedies for Non-Compliance with Determination of Violation. No later than 30 days after receipt of a Notice of Determination or, in the case of an Appeal, after an adverse final determination by a hearing officer, the contractor and/or subcontractor shall comply with the Notice of Determination of Violation by paying the amounts due for back wages and any penalty amount as set forth in the Determination of Violation or final determination. The contractor and/or subcontractor shall, in addition, be subject to the penalties set forth in Article V of this Chapter 6, including debarment. If any contractor and/or subcontractor fails to pay the amounts required under this subsection 6.22(e)(8)(E) within the required 30 days, the City may bring a civil action in a court of competent jurisdiction against the non-complying party and, upon prevailing, shall be entitled to such legal and equitable relief as may be appropriate to remedy the violation including, without limitation: (i) damages in the amount of back wages and any penalty amounts due to workers for violation of the prevailing wage requirement, which amounts the City shall, on receipt, distribute to workers following the procedures in subsection 6.22(e)(8)(D); and (ii) an award of reasonable attorney's fees and costs.
(f) Hours and Days of Labor.
(1) Generally. For the purpose of meeting prevailing conditions and enabling employers to secure a sufficient number of satisfactory workers and artisans, no person performing labor or rendering service in the performance of any Contract or subcontract for any Public Work or Improvement as defined in this Chapter shall perform labor for a longer period than five days (Monday through Friday) of eight hours each, with two 10-minute breaks per eight-hour day, except in those crafts in which a different work day or week now prevails by agreement in private employment. Any person working hours in addition to the above shall be compensated in accordance with the prevailing overtime standards and rates.
(2) Noncomplianceand Forfeiture. Any Contractor or subcontractor who shall violate any of the provisions of this subsection 6.22(f) shall be liable for the same penalties and forfeits as those specified in subsection 6.22(e) of this Chapter; penalties and forfeits shall be applicable for each laborer, mechanic or artisan employed for each calendar day or portion thereof whereon such laborer, mechanic or artisan is compelled or permitted to work more than the days and hours specified herein. The provisions of this subsection 6.22(f) shall be made a part of all Contracts and subcontracts for the construction of any Public Work or Improvement.
(3) Contracts Outside City and County. In the event that any Public Work or Improvement is to be constructed outside of the City and at such a distance therefrom that those engaged in performing labor on the Public Work or Improvement must under ordinary conditions remain at or near the site of the Public Work or Improvement when not actually engaged in the performance of labor thereon, then the officer, board or commission responsible for the construction of the Public Work or Improvement may, in making specifications or letting Contracts therefor, make provision therein for days and hours of labor beyond the limitations provided for in subsection 6.22(f) of this Chapter 6; but not to exceed eight hours in any one calendar day, or six days in any calendar week. In the event that emergency conditions shall arise, making a change advisable during the performance of any such Contract, or any portion thereof, the hours and days of labor may be extended beyond the limits hereinabove expressed; but not to exceed eight hours per day, upon the written authority of the officer, board or commission awarding such Contract. Failure of the Contractor to perform such Contract within the time provided shall not constitute an emergency.
(g) Local Hiring Policy. All Contracts and subcontracts for performance of Public Works or Improvements that exceed the Threshold Amount are subject to the requirements of the San Francisco Local Hiring Policy for Construction as set forth in Chapter 82 of the Administrative Code (“Local Hiring Policy”) and shall include compliance with the Local Hiring Policy as a material term of the Contract, directly enforceable by the City as described therein. As a condition of performance of Project Work, as that term is defined in Administrative Code Section 82.3, each Contractor and subcontractor agrees: to comply with all provisions of the Local Hiring Policy; that provisions of the Local Hiring Policy are reasonable and are achievable by the Contractor or subcontractor, including the reporting requirements and consequences for noncompliance described in Chapter 82 of the Administrative Code; and that the Contractor or subcontractor had a full and fair opportunity to review and understand terms of the Local Hiring Policy, in consultation with counsel if so desired.
(h) Modifications - Requirements. If it becomes necessary in the prosecution of any Public Work or Improvement Contract to make alterations or modifications or to provide for extras, such alterations, modifications or extras shall be made only on written recommendation of the Department Head responsible for the supervision of the Contract, together with the approval of the Mayor or the board or commission, as appropriate to the department, and also the approval of the Controller, except as hereafter provided. The Mayor or the board or commission, as appropriate to the department, may delegate in writing the authority to approve such alterations, modifications or extras to the Department Head, except as provided below. The Controller may delegate in writing the authority to encumber funds from prior appropriations for such alterations, modifications or extras to the Department Head prior to the certification for payment. Such authority, when granted, will clearly state the limitations of the changes to be encompassed.
(1) Increasing or Decreasing Price. Alterations, modifications, or extras in any Contract, which will increase or decrease the Contract cost or scope, may be made or allowed only on the written recommendation of the Department Head responsible for the supervision of the Contract stating the amount and basis for such increase or decrease. For any cumulative increase or decrease in price in excess of 10% of the original Contract price or scope, the Department Head shall obtain the approval of the Mayor or the board or commission as appropriate and also the approval of the Controller notwithstanding any delegation provided for above.
(2) Extensions of Time. Upon finding that work under a construction Contract cannot be completed within the specified time because of an unavoidable delay as defined in the Contract, the Department Head may extend the time for completion of the work. If the cumulative extensions of time exceeds 10% of the original Contract duration, the Department Head shall obtain the approval of the Mayor, board or commission, as appropriate to the department notwithstanding any delegation provided for above. The Department Head may seek such approval after completion of the work if the Department Head makes a written finding in the time extension that no basis exists to assess liquidated damages for delay against the Contractor. All time extensions shall be in writing, but in no event shall any extension be granted subsequent to the issuance of a certificate of final acceptance.
(A) Time Extension Not Waiver of City's Rights. The granting of an extension of time because of unavoidable delays shall in no way operate as a waiver on the part of the City or the Department Head, Mayor, board or commission of the right to collect liquidated damages for other delays or of the right to collect other damages or of any other rights to which the City is entitled.
(B) No Extension Granted When Contract Based on Time Estimates. When any Award of Contract has been made in consideration, in whole or in part, of the relative time estimates of Bidders for the completion of the work, no extension of time may be granted on such Contract beyond the time specified for completion, unless the liquidated damages for each day the work is uncompleted beyond the specified time shall be collected; provided, however, that this shall not apply to unavoidable delays as specified in the Contract.
(C) Avoidable and Unavoidable Delay; Limitation of Damages for Delay. The Department Head administering the Public Work or Improvement shall have the authority to specify in the Contract the delays that shall be deemed avoidable or unavoidable. The City shall not pay damages or compensation of any kind to a Contractor because of delays in the progress of the work, whether such delays be avoidable or unavoidable; provided, however, the City may pay for (1) delays caused to the Contractor by the City and (2) such unavoidable delays as may be specifically stated in the Contract. Such latter delays will be compensated for only under the conditions specified in the Contract.
(D) Notice of Delay Required. The Contractor shall promptly notify the Department Head in writing, of all anticipated delays in the prosecution of the work and, in any event, promptly upon the occurrence of a delay, the notice shall constitute an application for an extension of time only if the notice requests such extension and sets forth the Contractor's estimate of the additional time required together with a full recital of the causes of unavoidable delays relied upon. The Department Head may take steps to prevent the occurrence or continuance of the delay, may classify the delay as avoidable or unavoidable, and may determine to what extent the completion of the work is delayed thereby.
(i) Liquidated Damages. Any Contract may provide a time within which the Contract work, or portions thereof, shall be completed and may provide for the payment of agreed liquidated damages to the City for every calendar or working day thereafter during which such work shall be uncompleted.
(j) Progressive Payments Authorized; Retentions. Any Contract for construction services may provide for progressive or milestone payments, if the Advertisement For Bids shall so specify. Each progress or milestone payment shall constitute full compensation for the value of work performed and materials furnished for a specified period, less amounts withheld as a result of dispute or as required by law.
(1) For all Contracts entered into on or after the effective date of this subsection 6.22(j), from every progress payment, the City shall hold 5% in retention.
(2) Notwithstanding the subsection 6.22(j)(1) above, the City may hold greater than 5% but not more than 10% in retention if the Department Head responsible for the Public Work determines that the Public Work or Improvement is substantially complex and therefore warrants a higher retention amount, and the retention amount is specified in the Advertisement For Bids. For Contracts with retention amounts greater than 5%, if the Department Head responsible for the Public Work determines that the Contract is 50% or more complete, that the Contractor is making satisfactory progress, and that there is no specific cause for greater withholding, the Department Head, upon the written request of Contractor, may authorize one of the following two options: (A) the City shall release part of the retention to the Contractor so that the amount held in retention by the City, after release to the Contractor, is reduced to an amount not less than 5% of the total value of the labor and materials furnished, and the City shall proceed to retain 5% of any subsequent progress payment under the Contract; or (B) the City shall continue to hold the already withheld retention amount, up to 5% of the total Contract price, and shall not deduct further retention from progress payments.
(3) The Department Head shall authorize the release of retention, in whole or in part, for work completed by subcontractors certified by CMD as LBEs. The Department Head shall do so only upon a written request by the Contractor certifying (A) the work by the certified LBE subcontractor is completed and satisfactory in accordance with the plans and specifications for the project; (B) the total amount paid to the certified LBE subcontractor by the Contractor as of the date of the written request and the total amount of the subcontract; and (C) the amount of retention associated with the work performed by the certified LBE subcontractor. Following a release of such retention, and in order to calculate retention and retention withholding from further progress or milestone payments, the City will reduce the total retention required under the foregoing paragraphs (1) and (2) by the amount paid to the certified LBE subcontractor(s) for whom the City released the retention. The release of retention under this subsection 6.22(j)(3) shall not reduce the responsibilities or liabilities of the Contractor or its surety under the Contract or applicable law.
(4) The Department Head shall authorize the release of retention, in whole or in part, for work completed by subcontractors under any Public Work Contract awarded under this Chapter 6 with a duration of more than two years. The Department Head shall do so only upon a written request by the Contractor certifying (A) the work by the subcontractor is completed and satisfactory in accordance with the plans and specifications for the project; (B) the total amount paid to the subcontractor by the Contractor as of the date of the written request and the total amount of the subcontract; and (C) the amount of retention associated with the work performed by the subcontractor. The City may issue or authorize the release of retention within six months of the date of the request. Following a release of such retention, and in order to calculate retention and retention withholding from further progress or milestone payments, the City will reduce the total retention required under the foregoing subsections (1) and (2) by the amount paid to the subcontractor(s) for whom the City released retention. The release of retention under this subsection 6.22(j)(4) shall not reduce the responsibilities or liabilities of the Contractor or its surety under the Contract or applicable law.
(5) Retention shall be withheld solely for the benefit and protection of the City.
(6) When the Department Head responsible for the Public Work determines that the Contract is 98% or more complete, the Department Head may reduce retention funds to an amount equal to 200% of the estimated value of work yet to be completed, plus any amount necessary to cover offsets by the City for liquidated damages, defective work, stop notices, forfeitures, and other charges. The City shall release retention to the Contractor upon the following conditions: (A) the Contractor has reached final completion under the Contract terms and conditions and (B) the Contract is free of offsets by the City for liquidated damages, defective work and the like, and is free of stop notices, forfeitures, and other charges.
(7) For all Contracts awarded under this Chapter 6, in no event shall the City be liable for interest or charges arising out of or relating to the date the City issues any progress, milestone, or other payment, or the date the City releases all or part of the retention, except that the City will pay interest at the legal rate, as set forth in Section 685.010(a) of the California Code of Civil Procedure, as may be amended from time to time, on any improperly withheld amounts commencing no earlier than 90 days after the date the City should have made any progress payment or released all or part of the retention. Under no circumstances shall the legal rate of interest paid by the City under this provision exceed 10% per annum. The payment of interest under this provision is the limit of the City's liability with respect to any claim for interest on improperly withheld amounts.
(k) Inspection and Acceptance of Completed Work; Final Payment. The Department Head shall be responsible for the inspection and acceptance of Public Works or Improvements on completion. Such acceptance shall be in writing and shall include the certificate of the Department Head concerned that the work covered by the Contract has been fully and satisfactorily completed in accordance with the plans and specifications therefor. Receipt of copy of such acceptance in writing shall constitute the Controller's authority to complete any payments due the Contractor under the Contract; provided that the Controller may make such additional investigation or inspection as is provided by Administrative Code Section 10.07.
(l) Termination for Convenience. In all Contracts for the construction of any Public Work or Improvement, the Department Head may include in the specifications setting forth the terms and conditions for the performance of the Contract a provision that the City may terminate the performance of work under the Contract whenever the Department Head shall determine, with the approval of the Mayor or the board or commission concerned, that such termination is in the best interest of the City. Any such termination shall be effected by delivery to the Contractor of a notice of termination specifying the extent to which performance of work under the Contract is terminated and the date upon which such termination becomes effective. The Department Head is hereby authorized to include within such construction Contract the appropriate language to implement this subsection 6.22(l).
(m) Articles Not to be Prison Made. No article furnished under any Contract awarded under the provisions of this Chapter 6 shall have been made in a prison or by convict labor except for articles made in prisons or by convicts under the supervision and control of the California Department of Corrections and limited to articles for use by the City's detention facilities.
(n) Employment of Apprentices. All construction Contracts awarded under this Chapter 6 shall require the Contractor to comply with the requirements of the State Apprenticeship Program (as set forth in the California Labor Code, Division 3, Chapter 4 [commencing at Section 3070] and Section 1777.5), as it may be amended from time to time, and shall require the Contractor to include in its subcontracts the obligation for subcontractors to comply with the requirements of the State Apprenticeship Program.
(o) Safety. All construction Contracts awarded under this Chapter 6 shall require the Contractor and all of its subcontractors to abide by the applicable Occupational Safety and Health statutes and regulations.
(p) Claims. The City shall consider only those claims for additional payment under a Contract that are certified and that conform to the Contract requirements for claims, pricing, and schedule.
(1) Claims by Contractors. The Contractor shall certify under penalty of perjury that (A) the claim is made in good faith; (B) the supporting data are accurate and complete to the best of Contractor's knowledge and belief; and (C) the amount request accurately reflects the Contract adjustment for which the Contractor believes the City is liable. An individual or officer authorized to act on behalf of the Contractor shall execute the certification.
(2) Claims by Subcontractors. Subcontractors at any tier are not third-party beneficiaries of any Contract awarded under this Chapter. The City shall not consider a direct claim by any subcontractor. A Contractor presenting to the City any claim on behalf of a subcontractor must certify the subcontractor's claim in the same manner the Contractor would certify its own claim under the foregoing subsection 6.22(p)(1).
(q) Contractor Prompt Payment. All construction Contracts under this Chapter 6 shall require the Contractor to pay its subcontractors within seven calendar days after receipt of each progress payment from the City, unless otherwise agreed to in writing in advance by both Contractor and subcontractor. In the event that there is a good faith dispute over all or any portion of the amount due on a progress payment from a Contractor to a subcontractor, the Contractor may withhold the disputed amount but shall pay the undisputed amount.
Any Contractor who violates this subsection 6.22(q) shall pay to the subcontractor a penalty of 2% of the amount due per month for every month or portion thereof that payment is not made. This subsection 6.22(q) is enforceable in a court of competent jurisdiction, and is not intended to create a private right of action against the City.
(Added by Ord. 286-99, File No. 991645, App. 11/5/99; amended by Ord. 153-00, File No. 000805, App. 6/30/2000; Ord. 237-00, File No. 001207, App. 10/20/2000; Ord. 7-02, File No. 011675, App. 1/25/2002; Ord. 208-02, File No. 021221, App. 10/18/2002; Ord. 58-05, File No. 041571, App. 4/1/2005; Ord. 107-05, File No. 050215, App. 6/10/2005; Ord. 131-06, File No. 060444, App. 6/22/2006; Ord. 119-08, File No. 080277, App. 7/11/2008; Ord. 19-10, File No. 091163, App. 2/10/2010; Ord. 23-10, File No. 091233, App. 2/11/2010; Ord. 311-10, File No. 101311, App. 12/23/2010; Ord. 79-11, File No. 110330, App. 5/19/2011, Eff. 6/18/2011; Ord. 225-12, File No. 120750, App. 11/1/2012, Eff. 12/1/2012; Ord. 27-13
, File No. 121200, App. 2/19/2013, Eff. 3/21/2013; Res. 80-14, File No. 140091, App. 3/21/2014; Ord. 32-14
, File No. 140090, App. 3/27/2014, Eff. 4/26/2014, Oper. 6/25/2014; Ord. 85-14
, File No. 140151, App. 6/19/2014, Eff. 7/19/2014, Oper. 9/17/2014 (part); Ord. 108-15, File No. 150175, App. 7/2/2015, Eff. 8/1/2015; Ord. 224-15, File No. 150817, App. 12/22/2015, Eff. 1/21/2016, Oper. 4/20/2016; Ord. 84-17, File No. 170004, App. 3/30/2017, Eff. 4/29/2017, Retro. 3/25/2017; Ord. 220-20, File No. 200949, App. 11/6/2020, Eff. 12/7/2020; Ord. 164-23, File No. 230647, App. 7/28/2023, Eff. 8/28/2023)
(a) Public Works Less Than or Equal to the Threshold Amount. Any Public Work or Improvement estimated to cost less than or equal to the Threshold Amount may be performed by the employment of the necessary labor and purchase of the necessary materials and supplies directly by the City.
(b) Bids or Quotes by City Departments. Appropriate City departments may file Bids or submit Quotes for the execution of any work to be performed under a Contract and shall not be required to furnish security or submit information relative to financial qualifications as provided in this Chapter 6. Any Bid submitted by a department of the City, if it is the lowest Bid, must be approved by the Controller before the Award of the Contract. If the Bid of a City department, as investigated and approved by the Controller, is the lowest, the Contract shall be awarded to the department which shall record accurate unit costs of all direct and indirect charges incurred under any such Contract. Such unit costs shall be reported to and audited by the Controller monthly and on completion of the work.
The Controller shall maintain records of Bids filed by departments in relation to the total direct and indirect cost of each such work and shall report thereon periodically to the Mayor. The Controller may refuse to approve Contracts with a department shown to be repeatedly underbidding on Contract work and failing to complete same within the Contract price or time.
(c) Procedure Upon Rejection or Failure of Bids. When Bids have been advertised pursuant to the required procedures and a department receives no Bids, or only one Responsive Bid from a Responsible Bidder, the Department Head shall take the following actions, as appropriate:
(1) No Bids Received. If no Bids are received, the Department Head shall determine (A) whether further outreach efforts would result in Contractors submitting Bids and/or (B) whether removal or modification of certain requirements in the Contract would result in Contractors submitting Bids, provided that such requirements are not required by statute or law and their removal or modification would not compromise the interests of the City. If the Department Head determines that steps (A) and/or (B), above, would likely result in Contractors submitting Bids, then the Department Head shall re-bid the work. If the Department Head determines that neither step (A) nor (B), above, would likely result in Contractors submitting Bids, then the Department Head, with the approval of the Mayor or the board or commission concerned, as appropriate, may negotiate with any qualified Contractor or may order the work to be executed by the City.
(2) One Responsive Bid Received; No Other Bids Received. If only one Responsive Bid is received from a Responsible Bidder, and no other Bids are submitted for the same work, the Department Head may recommend the Award of a Contract to the sole Bidder at the bid price received, provided that the bid price does not exceed the engineer's estimate for the work. If the bid price received exceeds the engineer's estimate, the Department Head shall determine (A) whether further outreach efforts would result in more than one Bid and/or (B) whether removal or modification of certain requirements in the Contract would result in more than one Bid, provided that such requirements are not required by statute or law and their removal or modification would not compromise the interests of the City. If the Department Head determines that steps (A) and/or (B), above, would likely result in more than one Bid at bid prices substantially lower than the bid price received, then the Department Head shall re-bid the work. If the Department Head determines that neither step (A) nor (B), above, would likely result in more than one Bid at bid prices substantially lower than the bid price received, then the Department Head, with the approval of the Mayor or the board or commission for the department concerned, as appropriate, may negotiate with the sole Bidder or any qualified Contractor, or may order the work to be executed by the City. The cost of negotiated work or the cost of work executed by the City shall not exceed any bid price received for the same work.
(3) One Responsive Bid Received; Other Nonresponsive Bids Received. If only one Responsive Bid is received from a Responsible Bidder and other, nonresponsive Bids and/or Bids by nonresponsible Bidders are submitted for the same work, the Department Head may recommend the Award of a Contract to the sole Responsive, Responsible Bidder at the bid price received, provided that the bid price does not exceed the engineer's estimate for the work. If the Responsive bid price received exceeds the engineer's estimate, the Department Head shall determine (A) whether the qualifications for Bidders were too onerous and not necessary for the work and/or (B) whether one or more of the nonresponsive Bids could be easily cured and whether the Bidders that submitted such Bids are still interested in bidding on the work. If the Department Head determines that steps (A) and/or (B), above, would likely result in more than one Responsive Bid by Responsible Bidders, at bid prices substantially lower than the bid price received, then the Department Head shall re-bid the work. If the Department Head determines that neither step (A) nor (B), above, would result in more than one Responsive Bid by Responsible Bidders at bid prices substantially lower than the bid price received, then the Department Head, with the approval of the Mayor or the board or commission concerned, as appropriate, may negotiate with the sole Responsible Bidder or any qualified Contractor, or may order the work to be executed by the City. The cost of negotiated work or the cost of work executed by the City shall not exceed any bid price received for the same work.
(4) All Contracts awarded under this subsection 6.23(c), including negotiated Contracts, shall require that the substitution of subcontractors be in accordance with California Public Contract Code Section 4107.
![](https://export.amlegal.com/media/46db6a2ad42b2315973c5e4ca7298259402b7394/IMAGES/0-0-0-11760.png)
Publisher's Note: This section has been AMENDED by new legislation (Ord. 296-24
, approved 12/19/2024, effective 1/19/2025, oper. 2/19/2025). The text of the amendment will be incorporated under the new section number when the amending legislation is operative.
(a) Subject to the approval of the Mayor and Director of the Department of Administrative Services, the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer shall develop and administer a plan for the enforcement of the Prevailing Wage requirements and other labor standards imposed by the Charter and this Chapter 6 on Public Work or Improvements as defined in subsection 6.22(e). The Labor Standards Enforcement Officer shall coordinate his or her activities with federal and state labor standards agencies. The Labor Standards Enforcement Officer shall direct the City's enforcement of the Prevailing Wage requirements and other labor standards imposed by the Charter and this Chapter 6 on Contractors as directed by the Mayor, and to this end all City departments shall cooperate with the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer. The Labor Standards Enforcement Officer has the authority to seek for violations of Prevailing Wage, working conditions and apprenticeship requirements all of the penalties imposed by this Chapter, including the authority to file charges, in the same manner and to the same extent as a Department Head, which may lead to the debarment of the Contractor under Article V of this Chapter 6. The Labor Standards Enforcement Officer shall oversee the training of City personnel in the area of labor standards enforcement. In accordance with applicable law, the Mayor may enter into a contract for investigative and monitoring services to further the purposes of this Section 6.24. In evaluating the qualifications of persons seeking that contract, the Mayor shall consider, among other relevant factors, the experience of those persons in monitoring and investigating labor standards compliance.
(b) Subject to the fiscal and budgetary provisions of the Charter, the Office of Labor Standards Enforcement is authorized to receive from departments awarding contracts the amount reasonably calculated to pay for the costs, including litigation costs, of enforcing the City Prevailing Wage requirements and other labor standards for contracts awarded by those departments. The Labor Standards Enforcement Officer shall supervise the expenditure of all funds appropriated for enforcement of Prevailing Wage requirements and other labor standards imposed by the Charter and this Chapter 6 on Contractors.
(c) The Labor Standards Enforcement Officer shall establish an administrative procedure to address allegations of labor standards violations in connection with any contract under this Chapter 6. The Labor Standards Enforcement Officer shall have sole authority over the administration of this complaint procedure. The complaint procedure shall include but need not be limited to the following: (1) any person may file a complaint, written or oral, alleging one or more violations of any labor standards requirement imposed by this Chapter 6 on Public Work Contractors; (2) before beginning to investigate the complaint, the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer shall determine if the allegations of the complaint are sufficient and based on that assessment shall determine to either dismiss it or proceed with an investigation; (3) if the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer at any time determines that the allegations contained in the complaint are without merit, the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer shall notify the complainant; and (4) if the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer finds that any allegations in a complaint have merit, the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer shall proceed in accordance with the enforcement procedures under Section 6.22. This complaint procedure is applicable to allegations of labor standards violations in connection with any Public Work contract under this Chapter 6, but is not applicable to those matters under the administrative jurisdiction of the San Francisco Human Rights Commission. This procedure shall not preclude the Labor Standards Enforcement Officer from initiating or proceeding with an investigation on his or her own authority. All Contractors and departments engaged in Public Work shall cooperate fully with the Office of Labor Standards Enforcement in connection with any investigation of any complaint filed in accordance with this complaint procedure. The Labor Standards Enforcement Officer may interview, either at the worksite or elsewhere, any witness who may have information relative to a complaint.
(Added by Ord. 237-00, File No. 001207, App. 10/20/2000; amended by Ord. 208-02, File No. 021221, App. 10/18/2002; Ord. 8-03, File No. 021856, App. 1/31/2003; Ord. 5-06, File No. 051652, App. 1/20/2006; Ord. 108-15, File No. 150175, App. 7/2/2015, Eff. 8/1/2015)
Loading...